Why isn't there a fatwa against indian muslims for using government's money for doing their Hajj? - indian salam pak recipe
Indian government is investing a lot of money to travel around Rs 700 million rupees per year for the Muslims to Mecca .. Is this not anti-Islamic? Are we not actually with our own money to travel? Why no fatwa siisuing nonscientific and educate Muslims in this regard?
Salam and thanks
Wednesday, January 27, 2010
Indian Salam Pak Recipe Why Isn't There A Fatwa Against Indian Muslims For Using Government's Money For Doing Their Hajj?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
9 comments:
I do not know whether this number is correct from 700 million rupees. Every year approximately 200,000 Hadji India. They are Haji, 90,000 rupees for the first category, not least for the lower back and Riyals 2000 (more than 20,000 rupees), when it comes to Jeddah. I think that first one is the right answer to this ... Because the money did not steal or beg .. It's our own money is paid back again calculated on behalf of the "gift from the government. If the cost and the amount paid, not back when he ruled a profit. I also know that many Muslim rulers of India in this issue theme. By Allah (SWT) is that only those who can afford, Hajj ordained.
But one thing is certain, and all witnesses. India, although predominantly Hindu, but it is a democracy ... Indian Hajj Service is much better than many Muslim countries, its neighbors and beyond. Just arriving at the airport in Jeddah and see how many other nationalities to sleep on the floor of the airport for the day ... Some have even at the end under the bridges in the city of Jeddah.
People who can not afford, to the pilgrimage not obliged to go, but their intent is sufficient. "And Hajj (pilgrimage to Mecca) to the House (Ka'bah) is a duty that mankind is indebted to Allah, who are the costs," 3:97. Regarding the auspices of the government for everything I know that when someone gives a gift or someone Sadaqa and then turns the money used to make the pilgrimage, then there is no objection. But I know that some African countries (I believe that Nigeria is on) to the pilgrims on the ground that the person needs to pay his bill sponsor. And Allah knows best, SWT
Govt trick Hajj subsidy is necessary to reassure the Muslim voters,
Govt sponsored airline Air India is to maintain a monopoly, they decide on the fare. When the organizing committee for the hajj flights on their own, so they offer cheap flights.
What India Govt awards scholarships to Hadji and not just some, but also of Hindu pilgrimage.
and secular India Govt Govt must stop all thesesubsides used to be used for drinking water for the public.
Hadji, at least, if not the price for Hajj, do not.
I know nothing about, but I think it is a Muslim, something like love, which fund a scholarship to help future Hajjis is.
I know that here in Saudi Arabia as .. we can take to get people to help sponsor the Hajj, who never afford the luxury of his life .. I know that in Islam says that if you are paying can not be justified in life. But if it is people who are willing to charity sponsor, why not? ...
Hmm, I think it is acceptable. If the government gives me money and I know they will use for the Hajj, which is the problem here? Not that I'm stealing or obtaining a haram means to defraud the government?
No government taxes you pay when you work?
Religion and state must be separated. Would `nt want my Government, my taxes, of all religions miss denomanation.Aethiests don` t give go on a pilgrimage.
As the Indian Muslims are the taxpayers' money is
Or where can governemnates got his money?
The validity of the Hajj is not obligatory influenced by the fact that a number does not exist, one of his own money.
If all the conditions of Hajj and does not have all the essential parts of the Hajj, then (s) that you have fulfilled the duty of the Hajj, even if someone paid for it. [Al-Standing Committee for Scientific Research Consulting wa al-IFTA (Fatwa Commission, 11/34)]
There is absolutely nothing wrong with a person who leads the Hajj at the expense of another, if this person is your son, your brother or your friend, etc. This will not affect the validity of the Hajj pilgrimage because it is valid, the person must be their own money in his pilgrimage.
______________________________________ ...
Haram pilgrimage with the money!
Pilgrimage to Mecca is money valid, what the pilgrimage made by him is required, but will not be rewarded and not the pay is very low.
Al-Nawawi said in al-Majmoo (7 / 62): Doing Hajj with money from haram, then it is a sin, but his Hajj is valid and dischrged duty. This is the opinion of most lawyers.
In al-Legal Encyclopaedia (17/131), which says: If you do it with money from the hajj, or bad money that has taken her by force, his pilgrimage is valid according to the apparent meaning of the sentence, but a sinner, and his pilgrimage was not fully rewarded. This is the view of al-Shafi'i, Malik and Abu Hanifah (may Allah have mercy on them) and most scholars of earlier generations and beyond. Ahmad Ibn Hanbal said, "Your pilgrimage is not valid if the wealth is prohibited. According to another report is true, but it is haram. In a Sahih Hadith that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) mentions a man who travels a great distance, with wild hair, his hands extended toward heaven and said, 'Lord, Lord', but the food is Haram is his drink haram, haram, haram, his clothes are fed, as he can react?
Shaykh Ibn Baaz said:
His pilgrimage is valid only when prescribed by Allah, but it Sinning, because they held Haram survey. He must repent to Allah and his pilgrimage, which will be discussed below as haram income, but has fulfilled the obligation of Hajj. [Fataawa Ibn Baaz, 16/387.]
Said in the opinion of the Standing Committee (11/43) that the pilgrimage is haram, if the money does not mean that the pilgrimage is valid, but the person who is haram, sin, because wealth is acquired, but escape the wages of Hajj or invalidate the Hajj.
______________________________________ ...
The experts of the Standing Committee were asked: What is the decision on a pilgrimage to the detriment of the rule? This means that if an officer wants his people and said some money, go for the pilgrimage with the money. Is it acceptable that they make the pilgrimage with him or not? If they do Hajj with it that counts the obligatory Hajj?
They answered: It is permissible to do so, and his pilgrimage is valid, because the general meaning of the test. [The Standing Committee-Fataawa (11/36).]
To use, Goverlt Halaal.More more money government money belongs to all one.though! It is mixed with Halal & Haram!.
______________________________________ ...
I think someone who is not merciful to those Money.because discounted use [if it includes no money Haram] and makes you a sinner.
Yes, that's why the Muslims are still living in India have their own country in Pakistan. Not surprisingly, Indian cities of people die of hunger if the government fully subsidize these so-called pilgrims.
Yes put fatwa
You want to edit the hell do you keep silent beggar has a lot to Pakistan to rethink where you are most welcome. Why Hindus are money for you
Post a Comment